Bita na Ƙaunar Mumbai na Zamani: Dhruv Sehgal Ba Zai Iya Ajiye Amazon Prime Video Anthology Spin-Off ba

Ƙaunar zamani Mumbai - farkon ɗan Indiya na rom-com anthology na Zamani na Zamani, yanzu yana gudana akan Amazon Prime Video - yana buɗewa da kalmomi iri ɗaya da takwaransa na Amurka: "An yi wahayi ta hanyar rubutun sirri daga shafi na New York Times Love Modern. Wasu abubuwa an ƙirƙira su ne.” Amma abin mamaki, ba kamar na asali ba, Modern Love Mumbai bai bayyana wanda ya rubuta ginshiƙan sassan shida sun yi wahayi zuwa gare su ba. Me yasa yake boye sunayen marubutan? Yana haifar da tambayar: shin waɗannan labarun Mumbai na gaske ne waɗanda masu karatun Indiya na NYT suka gabatar? Ko - ku ƙyale ni tunani na baƙar fata - shin waɗannan labarun duniya an dasa su zuwa yanayin Indiya? Hakan ya faru da ni a wasu lokutan da na ga Soyayyar Zamani a Mumbai, fiye da haka saboda abubuwan da suka faru ba su jawo ni ba.

Hakan ya faru ne saboda yawancin labarunsa - kowane episode na Soyayya na Zamani a Mumbai ya keɓe, tun da tarihin ƙididdiga ne - suna humdrum. Yayin da wasu shirye-shiryen ke farawa da rashin ƙarfi kuma ba za su taɓa samun ku a gefen halayensu ba, wasu kuma suna farawa ta hanya mai ban sha'awa kawai su shuɗe daga ƙarshe. Mutane da yawa ba sa samun fahimtarsu, sun haɗa da tattaunawa mara kyau, ko yin abin lura. Kuma wasu suna yin cuɗanya da yawa a cikin lokutan gudu na mintuna 40. (Ina tsammanin wasu surori a cikin Love, Mutuwa + Robots kakar 3 na mako mai zuwa za su ba da ƙarin a cikin kusan kashi ɗaya cikin huɗu na lokacin.) Ko da yake akwai gazawar mutum ɗaya - har ma da sanannun hannaye a Vishal Bhardwaj, Hansal Mehta, da Shonali Bose falter, wasu ƙari. fiye da sauran - yana da wuya kada ku kalli hannun masu jagora kuma.

Yayin da The New York Times, da kuma mahaliccin Ƙaunar Zamani, darekta kuma mai gabatarwa John Carney suna da hannu a wasu iya aiki, Ƙaunar Zamani Mumbai shine samar da tutar Pritish Nandy. Kuma ba wai kawai wasu matsalolin iri ɗaya bane kamar yadda Firimiya Bidiyon su ke da'awar shahara, Ƙari Hudu Don Allah!, har ma da masu yin su. 'Ya'yan Pritish biyu, Rangita Pritish Nandy da Ishita Pritish Nandy, su ne furodusoshi kuma masu aiwatar da zartarwa a nan. Karin Harbi Hudu Don Allah! Marubuci kuma darakta na season 2 suma sun sami kashi na karshe na soyayya na Mumbai a kansu. Maimakon neman sabbin abokan tarayya don yin tarihin tarihin sa na rom-com, Amazon kawai ya juya ga mutanen da suka riga sun yi rom-com (matakin-mataki-mataki mai banƙyama). Ko da dandamali suna shiga cikin son zuciya yanzu.

Karin Harbi Hudu Don Allah! Bita na 2: Jerin Amazon ya ƙi girma

Masaba Gupta, Ritwik Bhowmik in Modern Love Mumbai "I Love Thane"
Kiredit Hoto: Amazon Prime Video

A ƙarshe an saita mashaya rahusa akan Ƙaunar Zamani Mumbai, kuma Ƙananan Abubuwan Mahaliccin Dhruv Sehgal - mafi ƙarancin ƙwararrun takwarorinsa anan, sabanin waɗanda aka ambata Bhardwaj, Mehta, da Bose - yana share shi ba kawai cikin sauƙi ba amma da kyau. Gajeren sa da kashi na biyar "I Love Thane" yayi kyau sosai a gaban sauran, kodayake kawai saboda kwatancen yana da tsauri. Ta hanyar ra'ayi na mai zanen shimfidar wuri a tsakiyar shekarunta 30 (Masaba Gupta) wanda ke fahimtar cewa ba ta cika ba kuma ba ta dace da yawancin maza ba - har sai ta sami damar samun wani saurayi daga Thane (Ritwik Bhowmik) wanda ke aiki a majalisar karamar hukumar - Sehgal da abokin aikinsa. -Marubuci Nupur Pai (Kananan Abubuwa Lokacin 3 da 4) taɓa abin da zance na kan layi yake kama da ma'ana ta gaskiya fiye da matakin saman-rikici na har abada da sha'awar soyayya.

Akwai wani harbi mai ban mamaki da ban dariya da wuri a cikin "I Love Thane", inda mata biyu suka kulle idanu yayin da suke nisanta daga abin da ke nuna biyu daga cikin mafi munin ranaku a duniya. A cikin 'yan seconds, Sehgal ba wai kawai yana ƙarfafa falsafar "maza suna s *** t" falsafar da aka kama a cikin tsararrakinmu ba, amma har ma ya skewers waɗanda ake zaton "masu sassaucin ra'ayi" da "mata" maza waɗanda suke da muni fiye da kishiyar polar su. "I Love Thane" yana sauka a cikin tsagi na yau da kullun na rom-com bayan wani batu, amma ƙaramin amma zurfin fahimta Sehgal ya zana wanda ya fice. Kuma mafi mahimmanci, Sehgal ba ya son yin sulhu a kan hangen nesa don kare masu sauraron Yammacin Turai - Ƙaunar zamani Mumbai kamar Indiyawa ke fuskanta, kamar yadda yake fuskantar waje, zan yi jayayya - sabanin abin da Hansal Mehta ya yi a kan "Baai", kashi na biyu. .

A kan "Baai", lokacin da wani hali ya bincika 'yar wasan kwaikwayo ta Bollywood, fassarar fassarar ta fassara shi zuwa Julia Roberts. Amma akan "I Love Thane", lokacin da haruffa suka kawo unguwannin kamar Thane, Bandra, da Naupada - an gabatar da su kamar yadda yake a cikin fassarar fassarar. Sehgal yana tsammanin masu sauraro su biyo baya, ko karantawa bayan sun gama shirin don fahimtar tattaunawa sosai inda wani hali ya koka da wani game da sanya su "tuki har zuwa Thane." Wannan shi ne yadda ya kamata. Bayan haka, haka Hollywood ta bi duniya. Gundumomin New York - aƙalla sunayensu - yanzu an san su a duniya. Ko da fim ɗin Marvel ba ya ɓad da kansa, lokacin da Kyaftin Amurka da Spider-Man suka yi ciniki akan Queens da Brooklyn. Kuma bai kamata mu ma muna yin hakan ba.

Likita Strange 2 Bita: Yawan Hauka na Hauka Yayi yawa kuma Ya Karanci

Pratik Gandhi in Modern Love Mumbai "Baai"
Kiredit Hoto: Amazon Prime Video

Mehta's "Baai" yana da 'yan abubuwan da ke faruwa a gare shi. Babban abin da ya fi dacewa a gare ni shi ne harbin farko da aka yi a cikin mota - darektan ya sake haɗuwa da Scam 1992 mai daukar hoto Pratham Mehta akan Ƙaunar Zamani a Mumbai - a lokacin tarzomar Bombay, wanda ke da gaske almara da ban tsoro. Ya tunatar da ni jerin jerin motoci na 'ya'yan maza, da kuma ɗaya daga cikin jerin abubuwan tunawa da na gani kwanan nan. “Baai”, wanda Mehta da mai gabatar da shirin Ankur Pathak suka rubuta, ya fara farawa mai kyau, amma ya ƙare da tururi. Mehta ya bi wani musulmi gay (Pratik Gandhi), tsiraru a cikin tsiraru - ba labarin LGBTQ + na farko ga darakta ba, ya kuma sanya Manoj Bajpayee ya jagoranci. Aligarh.

"Baai" yana yin duk abin da muka zo tsammani daga labarun game da mutanen LGBTQ+ a cikin al'ummomin da aka danne - akwai ainihin haɗar yadda tashin hankali ya fi yawa a cikin mazaje masu luwaɗi - amma yana tafiya saboda masu tayar da hankali. Wannan a bayyane yake daga takensa, wanda ke nufin kakar jarumar. Amma babbar matsalar Soyayyar Zamani a Mumbai kashi na 2 shi ne cewa ƴan wasan kwaikwayo — mashahurin mai dafa abinci kuma mai ba da abinci Ranveer Brar ya taka saurayin Gandhi kuma mijin na gaba - ba a yarda da su a matsayin mazan luwaɗi. Wurin daurin aure 👎🏼 ne kuma abubuwan sha'awar shagaltuwa sun sha dariya. Kamar suna murza fuska da jikkunansu da juna, maimakon rungumar juna da sumbatar juna.

Mehta kuma yana ƙoƙarin sanya abinci a tsakiyar labarinsa - kakarta an santa da girkinta, kuma halin Brar shine mai dafa abinci - amma ya ɓace a tsakiyar komai kuma baya shiga nasa. Vishal Bhardwaj yayi matukar kyau wajen yada labarinsa, "Dangon Mumbai", game da abinci. Kamar Mehta, Zaman Soyayya Mumbai kashi na 3 - wanda Bhardwaj da Jyotsna Hariharan suka rubuta - sun mai da hankali kan na waje. A nasa bangaren, 'yan Indiyawan 'yan asalin kasar Sin da ake ci gaba da yi da su kamar sauran, duk da shan wahala ta hanyar fiye da yawancin Indiyawa. (Labarin ya haɗu da Hindi, Cantonese, Punjabi, da Ingilishi.)

Daga Ƙaunar Zamani Mumbai zuwa Baƙon Abubuwa 4, Mafi Girman Yanar Gizo Tara a watan Mayu

Ko da yake Meiyang Chang's wannabe mawaƙin sake kunnawa yana samun ƙarin shirin, mahaifiyarsa ce (Yeo Yann Yann) wacce ke haskakawa kan Ƙaunar Zamani a Mumbai. Yabo a gare ta don yin rawar da ya fi yawa a cikin Hindi - ba za ta iya jin kamar na halitta ba, amma tana iyakar ƙoƙarinta. Mahaifiyar Yann tana rike danta babba ta hanyar abinci, don haka ta ke nuna soyayyarta. Duk da yake "Baai" wani bangare ne game da yadda abinci yake da gaske game da soyayya, "Dangon Mumbai" yana yin kyakkyawan aiki na isar da hakan. A cikin tatsuniyar Mehta, ya dushe a bango. Bai kamata ya zama mai dafa abinci mai kisa ba, amma ba ya cikin hoton - ya wuce. Bhardwaj ya ƙare nasa da cikakkiyar harbin abinci, wanda ke isar da fiye da tattaunawa ko ayyuka.

Akwai nau'ikan sassa na Bhardwaj na Zamani na Soyayya Mumbai. Ba wai kawai ya nufa a tsakiya ba, yana ciyarwa cikin hoto mai cike da kyakkyawan fata. Bollywood injin mafarki koyaushe yana sha'awar kunna tatsuniya, kodayake ina tsammanin ƙari daga wani kamar Bhardwaj. Ban yi tsammanin abubuwa da yawa daga Shonali Bose (The Sky Is Pink) da Alankrita Shrivastava (Dolly Kitty Aur Woh Chamakte Sitare), kuma duk da haka, labarunsu ba sa isarwa sosai.

“Raat Rani” — Kaunar Zamani a Mumbai kashi na 1, wanda Nilesh Maniyar ya rubuta (The Sky Is Pink) kuma ya fito da John Belanger wanda ya fara fitowa - shine kadai abin da ke faruwa game da mutanen da suka fadi cikin soyayya, ba a ciki ba. Babban abin da ke kawo cikas ga shirin Bose shine yadda Fatima Sana Shaikh ta Kashmiri lafazin na da ban dariya sosai. A saman wannan, ba za ku iya yin alaƙa da haruffan daga farkon ba saboda farawa yana da batsa. Amma mafi mahimmanci, "Raat Rani" ba ya samun ko ɗaya daga cikin abubuwan da ya faru. Gaba ɗaya ya rabu, yana tsalle daga abu ɗaya zuwa wancan. Bose yana son "Raat Rani" ya zama labarin ƙarfafa mata a zuciyarsa, amma manyan lokutan girma suna faruwa a kan allo.

Wannan kuma batu ne tare da "Kyawawan Wrinkles na" - wanda Shrivastava ya rubuta, takensa da kuma labarin kasa na Mumbai shima ba ya nan - inda aka ba da shawarar wata kakar (Sarika) wacce wani saurayi (Danesh Razvi) ke koyarwa, a cikin hanyar da yakamata ta zama cin zarafi. Duk da rashin kunya, Modern Love Mumbai kashi na 4 ba shi da kyau a ko'ina, kusan kamar yana jin kunyar nutsewa cikin abin da ke faruwa. "Kyakkyawan Wrinkles na" ya fizge cikin sauri, kuma ya ƙare a cikin kunci, fitar da salon, wanda ya nuna cewa ba shi da wani abu da za a ce mai daraja. Har ila yau, yana da mafi ƙarancin tattaunawa na kowane jigo a cikin wannan tarihin tarihin Bidiyo na Firayim, tare da haruffansa suna faɗin abubuwan da ake samu akan riguna da t-shirts. Yana da wani shari'ar Shrivastava zuwa takaice a kowane sashe.

Anyi a cikin Bita na sama: Jerin Amazon Game da Bikin aure na Indiya, Dukansu babba ne kuma mai kiba

Arshad Warsi, Chitrangda Singh in Modern Love Mumbai "Cutting Chai"
Kiredit Hoto: Amazon Prime Video

Wannan ya bar abin da na kira labarin son zuciya, domin shi ne wanda aka yi da wasu Harba Hudu Don Allah! kakar 2 darektan Nupur Asthana da marubuci Devika Bhagat. "Cutting Chai", tare da Chitrangda Singh da Arshad Warsi a matsayin ma'aurata a cikin shekaru arba'in, suna nuna matsalolin matsalolin maza na Indiya. Ba ni da wani abin da zan ƙara cewa, domin wannan shi ne ainihin jigon duka. Sai dai kashi na shida kuma na ƙarshe na Ƙaunar Zamani a Mumbai yana juyewa a cikin mintuna tara na ƙarshe, yayin da yake ƙoƙarin haɗa shi duka tare da ba da ma'ana ga jerin gabaɗayan a cikin tsari mai kyau.

Babu inda, Ƙaunar Zamani Mumbai ta lalata ƙayatarwa ta anthology akan "Cutting Chai", tare da haruffa daga sassa biyar na farko suna ɗaukar lokaci na ɗan lokaci. Ba abin mamaki ba ne ga waɗanda suka ga Soyayyar Zamani, domin ainihin ya yi haka, kamar yadda wani abokina ya sanar da ni. Wannan ba ya sa ya zama ƙasa da kwatsam ko da yake. Wasu al'amuran suna biyan kuɗi akan ƙudurin da suka gabata, amma tare da wasu, yana kama da sake duba raunin da ya gabata. Ƙarshe ce ta ɗan dace kuma, ta wata hanya, ƙarshen mafi muni, domin ta hanyar sake takawa da ba mu ƙanana na epilogues, Ƙaunar Zamani Mumbai kawai tana taimaka mana don tunatar da mu yadda ƙa'idar ta kasance.

Dukkanin sassa shida na Ƙaunar Zamani a Mumbai an fito da su Jumma'a, Mayu 13 da karfe 12 na safe IST akan Amazon Prime Video a Indiya da ko'ina cikin duniya.